This article may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep creating free content.

Smoked butter is one of those happy accidents. Leave a couple sticks of butter on the smoker while checking a pork butt, forget about them, and come back to find them half-melted and golden. Scrape it back together, chill it, and spread it on cornbread. It's genuinely one of the best things off a smoker.

Made intentionally, smoked butter becomes a favorite thing to hand out to friends. It takes almost no effort and it transforms everything it touches.

What You Need

1-2 pounds unsalted butter (good quality makes a difference)
A cast-iron skillet, sheet pan, or disposable aluminum pan
Your smoker and some mild wood

How to Make Smoked Butter (and Why You Should) — practical guide overview — How to Make Smoked Butter (and Why You Should)

That's it. Three things.

Why unsalted: You can always add salt later. Salted butter that concentrates during smoking can end up too salty. Start unsalted and season after for full control.

The Method

Cut the butter into pats. Slice each stick into 4-6 pieces and spread them out in a single layer on your pan. More surface area means more smoke absorption.
Set your smoker to 200 degrees F. You want low heat so the butter absorbs smoke before it fully melts. Some melting is fine and expected.
Use mild wood. Apple, cherry, or pecan. Hickory is too strong for butter and will overpower the delicate dairy flavor. Fruit woods are perfect here.
Smoke for 20-30 minutes. The butter will soften significantly and may partially melt. The surface will develop a light golden color and the edges may start to brown slightly.

Timing trick: If you're already smoking something else, just put the butter pan on the coolest spot of your smoker for the last 30 minutes of your cook. Free smoke, no extra effort.

After Smoking

Pull the pan off the smoker. The butter will be soft or partially melted. Scrape everything into a bowl, including any browned bits (that's where the flavor lives). Mix it all together with a spoon or spatula.

At this point you can add flavorings:

Classic: Pinch of flaky sea salt, done
Herb butter: Mix in chopped rosemary, thyme, and garlic
Honey butter: Drizzle in honey and a pinch of cinnamon
Spicy: Add your favorite BBQ rub or some chipotle powder

Roll the butter in plastic wrap into a log shape and refrigerate until firm. Or press it into a small dish or silicone mold.

Don't over-smoke: Butter absorbs smoke aggressively. More than 30 minutes and it starts tasting acrid and bitter. Keep it to the 20-30 minute window and you'll be in the sweet spot.

How to Use Smoked Butter

Everywhere you'd use regular butter, smoked butter is better:

On fresh cornbread straight from the oven
Melted over a grilled steak as a finishing butter
On baked potatoes (especially smoked baked potatoes)
Tossed with popcorn for movie night
Stirred into grits or mashed potatoes
Spread on a warm dinner roll

Gift idea: Wrap smoked butter logs in parchment paper, then in butcher paper, and tie with kitchen twine. Add a label with the wood type used. This makes an incredible homemade gift for anyone who cooks. It keeps 2-3 weeks refrigerated or 6 months frozen.

Once you try smoked butter, regular butter starts feeling like it's missing something. Because it is.